Eye Pencil Color Description BLACK Eye Pencil is a classicly rich, deep jet black. DARK TAUPE Eye Pencil is a rich, chocolately brown that creates a natural lash line.  NAVY Eye Pencil is a classicly rich, deep midnight blue universally flattering for any eye color and skintone. SMOKEY GRAY Eye Pencil is a beautiful alternative to black for fair to medium skintones and eye colors. Rich and luxurious, yet fresh and youthful.